I've got to admit, in recent times whenever I heard Taylor Swift songs on the radio, I found them all gratingly similar. She has a cute (ie youthful and innocent-sounding) voice and all, but I couldn't understand why her listeners were lapping up every single one of her singles, and turning them into instant hits and causing the DJs to give her repeated airplays. Don't get me wrong, I was already a semi-fan-on-my-way-to-being-sold status between her first and second album. But then, I lost my momentum when she came out with the songs Fifteen and You Belong With Me. I was like, "Taylor, please. Move on from that naive and desperate boyfriend-hungry image. You're not that young and innocent anymore." Needless to say, her new single Mine seemed like a shadow of her adorable Love Story song, on first listen.
At the end of the day, the only reason I got her Speak Now album on my hands was because, it seemed like a good deal at my time of purchase, with it being packaged as a "Deluxe Edition" at the CD store. And hey, I was always inclined to have a biased preference towards products of the pop culture nature. So, I was willing to give Swift a second chance. Once again, I proudly concede, the masses have chose right. :D I was only 3rd song in to listening the album, when it suddenly hit me that Taylor IS a brilliant song-writer. All the more so when I turned back to the front of the CD sleeve to see that she had written a two-page preface/introduction about the decision of the concept of her album, Speak Now (Please, for those in the dark, I highly urge you to buy her album just to read the visionary Ms Swift forever immortalized on those 2 pages :D). Her whole album is indeed an intimate revelation of herself, her journeys and experiences, and I/we thank her for openly sharing them with us.
Thank you Taylor, for bravely sharing your feminine discourse with the world. And now, it's my turn to speak now on Speak Now (pun intended).
**So here's the album review, according to the track listing. 5 Stars is full marks, there are no half stars rating.**
1)
Mine (SINGLE), 5 stars- Classic storytelling Taylor Swift, as she recounts the journey of her love story with her lover. A solid, easy-listening tune, albeit with Swift painting a more gritty and grown-up picture of the realities of being in a relationship. And yet at the same time, painting simple and surreal images with a touch of the fairytale magic,
"Do you remember when we were sitting there by the water, you put your arm around me for the first time,...Do you remember all the city lights on the water, you saw I started to believe for the first time". You gotta love the chorus, such an energetic outburst, in celebration of the couple's truimph over the odds. This song keeps growing on me by the number of replays on the repeated mode. There are so many good things with this song that keeps revealing itself one by one to me with each listen, that I don't think I'd have enough space to finish dissecting it. Lol. This is what a good song should be all about.
Noteworthy lines:
"I was a flight risk, with a fear of falling
Wondering why we'd bother with love, if it never lasts...
You made a rebel of a careless man's careful daughter
You are the best thing that's ever been mine"
2)
Sparks Fly, 4 stars- This song is an apt continuation from the previous Mine. Taylor shares her captivation of her lover, feeling like she's the lead actress to her charming leading man sweeping her off her feet in an epic romantic movie.
Noteworthy lines:
"Get me with those green eyes, baby
As the lights go down
Give me something that'll haunt me when you're not around
Cause I see, sparks fly whenever you smile"
3)
Back To December, 4 stars- That song with the other Taylor (Lautner,Twilight star). The fact that this song is about someone the rest of the world knows, and who watched their rocky relationship unfold, makes the song all the more real and sad with the title pinpointing the period, back in December. Swift sounds really sorry and wistful, with the bridge
"maybe this is wishful thinking, probably mindless dreaming, If we loved again I swear I'd love you right. I'd go back in time and change it but I can't, So if the chain is on your door, I understand." As well as coupled with the barrage of start-stop words in the chorus lines, sung out in a fashion as if Taylor was reading out loud her apology from her songsheet. This song has such a sorrowful yet excellent time-turning feel to it, with its musical arrangement.
Noteworthy chorus:
"So this is me swallowing my pride,
standin' in front of you, sayin' I'm sorry for that night
And I go back to December all the time
It turns out freedom aint nothin' but missin' you, wishin' I'd realized what I had when you were mine
I go back to December, turn around and make it alright
I go back to December all the time"
4)
Speak Now, 3 stars- This is a cutesy and fun song with a serious undertone, that of not taking marriage lightly when one is making a lifelong commitment to the other person. Although I don't like Taylor recycling the theme of chiding the boy for choosing the other (and so wrong) girl over her (come on Taylor, you're better than these wimpy boys who don't know what they've missed), it got me thinking that this song probably speaks to a lot of people out there. How many movies have been made about the groom regretting marrying the wrong girl, and there's nothing he nor the yearning nice girl in the sidelines can do about it? This is probably a good warning message from Taylor to her youthful fanbase, out there, to "speak now, or forever hold your peace" and hence, save the world, one (youthful and reckless) bad marriage at a time.
Noteworthy lines:
"I am not the kind of girl
Who should be rudely barging in on a white veil occasion
But you are not the kind of boy
Who should be marrying the wrong girl"
5)
Dear John- 4 stars- Another song about another guy which the whole world is clued into. At first when I saw the title on the back sleeve, I thought, 'wtf, Taylor Swift sang on the soundtrack of
that sappy Nicholas Sparks movie??' But nooo, thank god, this song is not anything about longing for her soldier man fighting in a land far far away. It's about none other than that pussy badboy rocker Mr John Mayer, who had a short hook-up with her early this year. Revenge is never sweeter than calling him out in a song, and including it on an album which would guarantee go platinum several times around the world. This song would have been given 5 stars if Taylor had injected more angst in it. But you know, Ms Taylor is just too classy and nice for that. Instead, I guess she makes that John all the more mortified by gaining public sympathy with this song resonating with strong heartbreaking regret of her moment of youthful, gullible, starry-eyed folly.
Anyone thinks the electric guitars ringing in here are purposely made to sound like Mayer's? Genius. Wallow in your own bile Mayer, by reflecting on these lines served fresh on a big bowl to you:
Noteworthy lines
"Maybe it's you and your sick need to give love and take it away.
And you'll add my name to your long list of traitors who don't understand....
Dear John,
I see it all now, it was wrong.
Don't you think nineteen's to young to be played by your dark, twisted games
when I loved you so?
I should've known."
Here's my own separate note to another boy,
Dear David (Archuleta), you've got a thing or two to learn about songwriting from Ms Taylor here. America's reigining sweetheart made it to the top herself without needing no reality show backing up her name yo.
6)
Mean, 2 stars- Me thinks if you're gonna make a told-you-so song to a real life meanie, you should do it properly, and not in a nicey-nice way. But of course, Taylor can't afford to spoil her sweetheart image, so she turns this song to her advantage by turning it into Country kitsch. The lyrics in the chorus can't get redneckish enough,
"Someday I'll be big enough so you can't hit me. And all you're ever gonna be is mean." The glue that holds this song together are the instrumentals-the bright, nimble mandolin sounds and sharp violins which gives the dramatic and piercing effects, turning her accusations into clever sing-song effect and now being the one whose
"words(are now)
like knives and swords and weapons that you (she)
use against"
My favourite lines are when she dishes it:
"All you are is mean
And a liar
And pathetic
And alone in life
And mean, and mean, and mean, and mean"
7)
The Story of Us, 1 star- What a bad follow-up choice to the previous Country song. This song belongs more to a Taylor Swift remixed album, with its techno sound. The story of us should never have been told. I give it props for being...different, in a bad way.
I-told-you-so lines:
"And the story of us looks a lot like a tragedy now...The End"
8)
Never Grow Up, 2 stars- I would hate to be told, "Never grow up" by my parents, so at first I was like, "wtf Tay, everyone can't wait to grow up." After a few listens however , I realized she is speaking to every one out there who still wants to hold on to the innocence in themselves, no matter how small, that holding on to the carefree ways of childhood is what people wished they could have cherished more when younger. I really wanted to root for this song, but the solo guitar is arranged way TOO simply (I've heard many of those, and unless you have an amazing voice, this would sound boring, which it is bordering on). Wished Taylor had injected more country flavour and authenticity into it, by adding in a couple more instruments.
9)
Enchanted, 5 stars- (In Tay's words)
All I can say is, Taylor is a darn good fairytale storyteller of lovers. This song encapsulates the greeting reply of "Enchanté" (while the guy kisses your hand)
perfectly. Siiigh.
Noteworthy lines:
"This night is sparkling, don't you let it go...
I was enchanted to meet you"
10)
Better Than Revenge, 3 stars- This is Techno Taylor Remix Part 2. Taylor tries to sound badass in an Avril Lavigne way but...it's just not Tay's style. Pls stick with what you do best Taylor! Again, i gave it this 3 stars rating because it sounds better than the other techno song (aka Track No. 7) This song would also have fitted right in on a pop-rock album though.
11)
Innocent, 3 stars- I like the juxtaposition of this introspective slow-paced song with the underlying empowering message. People are saying this is Taylor forgiving Kanye West after what he
infamously did to her at the MTV VMAs last year. Sometimes, inspiration comes from strange places, like those once-in-a-life-time-on-TV moments. Whatever it is, this song has more heart than Never Grow Up.
Noteworthy lines
"It's okay life is a tough crowd
32 and still growing up now
Who you are is not what you did
You're still an innocent"
12)
Haunted, 3 stars- And Tay's angsty Avril/Alanis side resurfaces again here. I like the way she's experimenting with her vocals. Very dramatic stuff, but a bit out of place on an album packaged as Country.
Noteworthy chorus:
"C'mon, c'mon don't leave me like this
I thought I had you figured out
Something's gone terribly wrong
You're all I wanted
C'mon, c'mon don't leave me like this
I thought I had you figured out
Can't breathe whenever you're gone
Can't turn back now
I'm haunted"
13)
Last Kiss, 4 stars- A haunting, beautiful love song. You can really feel Tay's sadness and emotions coursing through her. This track was thoughtfully written and produced as well with-the piano, organ, violin, and solo guitar parts in there.
Noteworthy chorus:
"I never thought we'd have a last kiss
I never imagined we'd end like this
Your name forever the name on my lips"
14)
Long Live, 5 stars- Storytelling at its best when compressed into a song like this. The length of this last song off her album, is 5:17. LOVE this. Such an anthem for Truimph. Can this song be listed in the next Twilight or Harry Potter movie already?? (I'm gunning for Twilight all the way because, it has a strong female lead :D) I would also love to see this song released as a single, but with its length, it's very unlikely.
Noteworthy lines:
"Long live the walls we crashed through
All the kingdom lights shined just for me and you
I was screaming, "long live all the magic we made"
And bring on all the pretenders
One day we will be remembered...
Long live the walls we crashed through
I had the time of my life with you"
Overall verdict of album, 3.4 stars- In the spirit of just coming off reviewing the very last song on Swift's album, I say, "Long live Queen Taylor! Yes you, all decked out in the royal purple colour in the original standard album cover (and in red for the Deluxe edition). There may be some misses in her album, but there ARE real gems as well, and at the good progress she's maturing in her songwriting, keep bringing on the songs, Swifty!
Ed's note: PS, I have NO idea why Blogspot can't get my spacings right.